Catering

Deli Trays

Deli Sandwich Tray

An assortment of Katzinger’s famous sandwiches, halved and frill-picked, on a variety of breads. Corned Beef, Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Honey Ham, Salami, Smoked Turkey, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad and Vegetarian; Lettuce, Tomato and Onion Slices, condiments including Homemade Russian Dressing, Imported Olives, and of course, garlic and dill Pickles. Your choice of two homemade salads: Traditional Potato Salad, Olive Oil dressed Red Skin Potato Salad, Creamy Coleslaw or Macaroni Salad.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $110
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $170
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $235
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $325

Deli Tray Plus

This tray has been our hands-down favorite since we opened in 1984 – and it is still a bargain! Corned Beef, Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Honey Ham, Hard & Soft Salamis, Emmentaler Swiss, Vermont cheddar & Muenster Cheeses. Your choice of two homemade salads: Traditional Potato Salad, Olive Oil dressed Redskin Potato Salad, Creamy Coleslaw or Macaroni Salad; a variety of freshly baked breads, lettuce, tomato, onion and condiments including homemade Russian Dressing, Imported Olives and, of course Dill and Garlic Pickles!
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $110
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $160
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $235
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $375.

Wraps & Sams Tray

This tray just mixes it all up. Corned Beef, oven Roasted Turkey Breast, Chicken Salad, Grilled Chicken, Honey Ham, Roast Beef all on a variety of breads and wraps adorned with cheese and condiments. We include your choice of Fresh Fruit or Greek Salad, Pickles, Olives and Kettle Potato Chips.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $115
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $185
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $255
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $350

Box Lunches

Katzinger’s Entree Salad Bag – Choose from 2 spectacular entrée salads for one guest. Both options include fresh fruit, freshly baked bread and butter and, of course two homemade cookies. Homemade dressings include Balsamic Vinaigrette, Greek, Ranch, Russian, Oil & Vinegar and Blush Vinaigrette and are served on the side.

Box Lunches

Katzinger’s Classic Deli Box Choose one Classic sandwich on an assortment of fresh baked breads: Corned Beef, Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Honey Ham, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Veggies in a Pita Choose one homemade salad:
  • Traditional Potato Salad
  • Redskin Potato Salad
  • Macaroni Salad
  • Coleslaw
And yes, every box comes with two of those yummy homemade cookies and of course pickles. $10.95 each

Katzinger’s (Remixed) Chicken Caesar Salad

Slices of our marinated, then grilled chicken breast, fresh mesclun greens, freshly grated Parmesan cheese. Caesar dressing with a hint of anchovies served on the side $15.25

Katzinger’s Greek Salad

Tangy feta cheese chunks, marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red pepper strips, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, and kalamata olives on salad greens. $14.95 Add grilled chicken slices for $3 more

Desserts

Katzinger’s Brownie & Ruggie Tray

Katzinger’s Homemade Ruggies (or Rugelach) are wonderful, rich cream cheese and butter cookies rolled with a variety of fillings. They join our brownies for an extra treat.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $40
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $60
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $80
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $110

Our Brownie & Cookie Assortment

When you just can’t decide, we say well, just go ahead and enjoy both.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $30
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $45
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $60
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $80

Our Homemade Brownie Tray

A selection of our truly delectable homemade brownies, lightly garnished with fruit.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $30
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $45
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $60
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $80

Our Homemade Cookie Assortment

Katzinger’s yummy homemade chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and peanut butter cookies.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $30
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $45
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $60
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $80

Entrée and Side Salads

Entrée Salads for a group – Minimum of 5 per salad. Homemade dressings include Balsamic Vinaigrette, Greek, Ranch, Russian, Oil & Vinegar and Blush Vinaigrette and are served on the side.

Fresh Fruit Bowl

The freshest possible seasonal fruit cut into delectable bite-sized chunks.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $30
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $45
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $65
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $85

Katzinger’s Greek Side Dish

Chunks of tangy feta cheese, chopped cucumber, tomato, red onion and Kalamata olives, dressed with our homemade Greek salad dressing. Very authentic and very delicious.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $25
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $40
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $60
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $80

Strawberry Fields Forever Greens Salad

An in-house medley of mixed salad greens, fresh spinach and creamy goat cheese topped with fresh strawberries and walnuts. Served with our Berry Vinaigrette on the side.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $40
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $60
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $80
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $105

Tossed Salad Bowl

Fresh salad greens tossed with tomatoes, cucumbers, and red onion slices. Served with 2 of our homemade Salad Dressings. We recommend our Ranch (may be the best you’ll ever taste) and Balsamic Vinaigrette. Or choose 2 from the following Oil & Vinegar, Greek or Berry Vinaigrette – all delicious and served on the side.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $25
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $35
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $50
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $70.

Appetizers

Deluxe Cheese & Fruit Board

Five of our most popular cheeses, laden with fruit and accompanied by crackers and freshly baked Katzinger’s baguette slices.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $55
  • Small (Serves 12-15) $90
  • Large (Serves 25-30) $140

Deviled Eggs

We offer four distinct, very yummy fillings. Order all or choose your favorite. Please allow 24 hours’ notice.
(3 dozen minimum per filling)
Tarragon, Sundried Tomato or Americana (a classic deviled egg)
$10 per dozen
Smoked Nova Salmon
$15 per dozen

Exquisite Cheese Board

For the true Cheese aficionado we serve wedges of fine artisan cheeses accompanied by Marcona almonds, cornichons, and a perfectly matched jam or honey. Served with crackers and fresh-baked Katzinger’s baguette slices.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $75
  • Small (Serves 12-15) $145
  • Large (Serves 25-30) $250

Katzinger’s Authentic Antipasto Platter

A true Italian styled feast of an appetizer – various garlicky salamis, including Capicolla, Sopressata & Genoa, along with prosciutto slices, Provolone cheese, bread sticks, imported olives, marinated artichokes, peppers and cherry tomatoes.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $55
  • Small (Serves 12-15) $80
  • Large (Serves 25-30) $135
 

Katzinger’s Hot Mini Grills

Selection of our most popular grilled sandwiches – in miniature (minimum order of 2 dozen & please choose a quantity of 6 or 12 for each sandwich).
$35 per dozen
  • #1. Katzinger’s Reuben – need we say more?
  • #9. Jimmy’s Photo Finish - pastrami, Swiss cheese, onion, hot mustard
  • #11. Janis’ Special Can-Do - smoked turkey, Muenster cheese, Honeycup mustard
  • #16. Be’s Bustling Birdwich - turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, Russian dressing
  • #57. Franklin’s Kibbetz - Katzinger’s homemade fresh mozzarella, our own homemade pesto, tomato

Katzinger’s Mediterranean Relishes

An ethnic twist to an old favorite. Fresh-cut crudité accompanied with homemade hummus, dilled yogurt dip and marinated artichoke hearts, dolmas, imported olives and pita triangles.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $40
  • Small (Serves 12-15) $70
  • Large (Serves 25-30) $100

Katzinger’s Mini Deli Sandwiches

A varied selection of favorites from the Katzinger’s sandwich menu – in miniature (minimum order of 2 dozen & please choose a quantity of 6 or 12 for each sandwich).
$35 per dozen
  • #12. Norman’s Special II with turkey, roast beef, Muenster cheese, lettuce, red onion, Russian dressing
  • #21. Gene’s Free Lunch with corned beef, roast beef, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing
  • #46. Repast of the Robber Baron with turkey, lettuce, tomato and mayo
  • #32. Andy’s Got Another Job with smoked turkey, honey ham, scallion cream cheese, tomato and Honeycup mustard
  • #41. Phil’s Katzinger’s Club with Homemade chicken salad, Applewood smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard
  • #54.  Doug’s Vegetarian Head Plant (vegan)  Garlicky marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red pepper, spinach, cucumber, lettuce, tomato in a pita.
  • Tuna salad served in pita
  • Chicken salad served in pita

Rachel Knows Best Spicy Pimento Cheese Platter

As seen on PBS’ Barefoot Contessa! Traditional taste of the South pimento cheese spread with pizazz added!  Served with toasted pita, pumpernickel wedges, cucumber slices, carrot and celery sticks. All you need is a Gin Fizz!
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $45
  • Small (Serves 12-15) $70
  • Large (Serves 25-30) $105

Sauerkraut Balls

Accompanied with spicy mustard and Russian dressing... You won’t believe how good these are! Please allow 48 hours’ notice. 3 dozen minimum.
$12 per dozen

Breakfast and Brunch

Bodacious Bagel Tray

A selection of fresh-baked bagels accompanied by cream cheese, butter, preserves and a light fruit garnish.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $45
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $60
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $80
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $115

Breakfast Assortment

A selection of fresh-baked muffins and bagels accompanied by cream cheese, butter, preserves and a light fruit garnish.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $55
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $75
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $95
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $150

Freshly Baked Muffins

A selection of fresh-baked muffins accompanied by butter, preserves and a light fruit garnish.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $45
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $60
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $80
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $115

Great Smoked Fish Tray

The finest smoked fish in town and very generous portions. Perfect for breakfast or brunch. Nova, Smoked Whitefish, assorted bagels, cream cheese, scallion cream cheese, butter, cucumber, tomato and onion slices.
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $160
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $265
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $385
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $550

Homemade Coffee Cake

Fresh house made Coffee Cake, sliced and presented on a tray with a light fruit garnish. Each cake serves 10-12.
$28

Luscious Homemade Deep Dish Quiche

Made to order in our own kitchen using only the finest ingredients. Choose from: Classic Lorraine • Broccoli, Mushroom & Cheddar • Broccoli & Ham • Roasted Red Pepper and Marinated Artichoke. Each quiche serves 10-12 persons and is excellent served at room temperature. Please allow 48 hours notice.
$35 each

The Dairy Salad Tray

Perfect for brunch, lunch or light dinner. Katzinger’s homemade tuna salad and egg salad with bagels, rye bread, cream cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, pickles and olives. Very simple, very delicious. For an extra treat add smoked Nova Scotia salmon!
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $75
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $125
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $175
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $245
With Smoked Nova Salmon
  • Mini (Serves 5-7) $125
  • Sm. (Serves 10-12) $190
  • Med (Serves 15-18) $275
  • Lg. (Serves 25-30) $395

Beverages

  • Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mist Twist, Diet Mist Twist, Dr Pepper, Diet Dr Pepper $1.50 + tax per can  
  • Bottled Spring Water $1.75
  • Dr Brown’s Soda: Cream, Diet Cream, Black Cherry, Diet Black Cherry, Ginger Ale, Cel-Ray. Root Beer $1.75 + tax
  • Coffee Boxes-serve 8-10, comes with cream, sugar/sweetener, cups, and stirrers $25
  • Paper plates, plastic utensils and napkins are available at $1.00 per person.

Ordering Details

All catering orders are taken by an experienced, knowledgeable person (yep, a real live smiling person! Here at Katzinger’s we call them our “catering experts”).

Please email, call (614) 228-3354 or use our contact form to inquire about placing a catering order. Email and form submissions are monitored Monday-Friday, 8:30 a.m.-5:30 p.m. EST.

  • We request 24 hours’ notice to guarantee most catering orders up to 150 people.  For a larger event, we appreciate 48 hours’ notice.  As always, we will try our best to accommodate your last-minute needs.
  • We cannot accept changes or cancellations the day of your order. Last minute cancellations may incur up to a 35% cancellation fee.
  • Orders that contain specialty items (such as items we bring in just for you) may require up to a 50% non-refundable deposit.  
  • Availability and price are subject to change without notice so we may need to make comparable substitutions.
  • We do deliver. Charges vary with your delivery address.
  • Payment is expected at the time of delivery or pick up via cash, company check, Visa, MasterCard, Discover, or American Express. Please provide a credit card at time of placing order to guarantee your order.
  • Food Allergies- Please be aware that food prepared here may contain these ingredients: milk, eggs, wheat, soy products, peanuts, tree nuts, fish and shell fish.
  • We are happy to send you a credit application for a direct billing account.
  • We thank you for your trust in Katzinger’s Catering.  Please let us know if for any reason we disappoint you.  We will do whatever is possible to make it right.
  • Of course, prices and availability are subject to change without notice.
Return to Top
Experience Columbus
© Copyright 2018 Katzinger’s Delicatessen | All Rights Reserved | 475 S. 3rd Street, Columbus, OH 43215